Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of hotels in Montauk, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Haven Montauk Hotel |
8.6 / 10 (608 Reviews) |
From 105$ | |
| Hero Beach Club |
8.0 / 10 (117 Reviews) |
From 245$ | |
| Montauk Yacht Club Hotel |
8.0 / 10 (176 Reviews) |
From 335$ | |
| The Surf Lodge |
6.8 / 10 (26 Reviews) |
From 375$ | |
| Marram Hotel |
8.5 / 10 (280 Reviews) |
From 383$ |
Montauk, United States, offers a unique blend of luxury and sophistication in its range of 4-star accommodations. From elegant boutique hotels to lavish resorts, there is something for every discerning traveler seeking an upscale experience. Immerse yourself in the opulence and comfort of Montauk's finest establishments, where impeccable service and top-notch amenities await. Whether you prefer oceanfront views, spa indulgence, or gourmet dining, these 4-star luxury hotels in Montauk promise an unforgettable stay.
View all photos
Haven Montauk Hotel
From 105$
- Free Wi-Fi
- Free parking
- Luggage storage
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Flat-screen TV
- Electric kettle
- Sun loungers
- Beach umbrellas
The property lies in the very heart of Montauk, a few steps from Gosman's Dock. The hotel is 5 minutes' walk of Montauk Marine Basin and 115 km from Long Island MacArthur airport.
View all photos
Hero Beach Club
From 245$
- Free Wi-Fi
- Free parking
- Seasonal outdoor pool
- Air conditioning
- Cots
- Board games
- Beach access
- Sun loungers
- Beach umbrellas
- Full body massage
The accommodation is placed about 110 km from Long Island MacArthur airport and 400 metres to Kirk Park Beach. Second House Museum is only a short distance from the hotel in Montauk. Visit Fort Pond, at 1.5 km distance from this property, and feel complete harmony with the nature of United States. Guests can find Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, which is within 2.8 km away.
Luxurious Seaside Retreats in Montauk
Experience the epitome of coastal luxury with a stay at one of Montauk's upscale beachfront hotels. From spacious suites with panoramic ocean views to exclusive access to private sandy shores, these 4-star properties redefine seaside indulgence. Pamper yourself with rejuvenating spa treatments, savor delectable seafood cuisine, and unwind in elegant surroundings that embrace the beauty of Montauk's shoreline.
View all photos
Montauk Yacht Club Hotel
From 335$
- Wi-Fi in rooms
- On-site car park
- 24-hour reception
- 24-hour security
- Seasonal outdoor pool
- Seasonal indoor pool
- Air conditioning
- Children's pool
- Cots
- Beach access
Enjoying a private location in a beach area, the property is just off Star Island Yacht Club and Marina. A popular place in Montauk is Second House Museum, which is 10 minutes' ride away. Guests can find a charming beach within a stroll of the hotel. A 10-minute walk of Gurney'S Star Island Resort & Marina there is Montauk Marine Basin.
View all photos
The Surf Lodge
From 375$
- Wi-Fi
- Flat-screen TV
The centre of Montauk can be reached within 15 minutes' walk of The Surf Lodge. Kirk Park Beach is 1.6 km of the hotel, and Long Island MacArthur airport is 110 km away. Visit Fort Pond, 50 metres of this luxury property, and feel complete harmony with the nature of United States. A 10-minute drive from The Surf Lodge, guests will also find Gosman's Dock.
Boutique Elegance in Montauk's Trendy District
Discover the charm and sophistication of Montauk's boutique 4-star hotels nestled in the heart of the trendy district. Each property offers a unique blend of personalized service, stylish accommodations, and exclusive amenities that cater to the discerning traveler. Explore the vibrant local scene, from chic shops to upscale dining establishments, and immerse yourself in the eclectic culture of Montauk's bustling neighborhood.
View all photos
Marram Hotel
From 383$
- Free Wi-Fi
- Free parking
- Seasonal outdoor pool
- Air conditioning
- Cots
- Beach access
- Private beach
- Sun loungers
- Beach umbrellas
- Hiking
The property is placed about 110 km from Long Island MacArthur airport and an easy walk to Sunset Surf Shack. You'll be 1.2 km of Fort Pond. The celebrated Ditch Plains Beach is accessible within a 25-minute walk.
Hotels in Montauk
| Airport nearby ✈️ | Hartford-Brainard, Tweed-New Haven, Long Island MacArthur, T.F. Green |
| Average Price 💰 | 687$ |
| Hotels in Montauk 🏨 | 45 |
| Hotel Reviews ⭐ | 736 |
| Landmarks nearby 📍 | Hither Hills State Park, Montauk Lighthouse Museum, Camp Hero State Park, Shadmoor State Park, Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course |
| Family Hotel 👪 | Haven Montauk Hotel |
| Top Service Hotel 🛁 | Hero Beach Club |
| Hotel with balcony 🌤️ | Montauk Yacht Club Hotel |
Rustic Chic Retreats in Montauk's Countryside
Escape to the tranquility and serenity of Montauk's countryside with a stay at a luxury 4-star retreat nestled amidst nature's beauty. These rustic chic properties offer a perfect blend of cozy charm and upscale comfort, featuring spacious cabins, private cottages, and secluded villas. Indulge in farm-to-table dining experiences, outdoor adventures, and relaxation in a picturesque setting that captures the essence of Montauk's natural landscapes.
Modern Sophistication in Montauk's Downtown
Immerse yourself in the vibrant energy of Montauk's downtown district with a stay at one of the city's modern 4-star hotels. Boasting sleek design, contemporary amenities, and convenient access to top attractions, these properties offer a perfect mix of style and substance. Enjoy gourmet dining options, rooftop bars with stunning city views, and upscale accommodations that cater to the urban explorer seeking luxury in the heart of Montauk.
Historic Grandeur in Montauk's Heritage Hotels
Experience the rich history and timeless elegance of Montauk's heritage 4-star hotels, where classic charm meets modern luxury. Step back in time with a stay at these iconic properties, housed in historic buildings that have been meticulously restored to their former glory. Indulge in luxurious suites, fine dining experiences, and unparalleled service that pays homage to Montauk's distinguished past while providing all the comforts of a contemporary luxury retreat.